The Baby Matrix by Laura Carroll

Baby matrix

Published: 2012 by LiveTrue Books
My copy: Bought on Kindle

Memorable quote: “Without expectations, the bond between marriage and parenthood is fully released from pronatalist grips. Couples are free to choose whether they want parenthood to be part of their marital experience. Without expectations, we can also let go of the other pronatalist belief that parenthood should be part of every person’s experience of life.”

Books on the childfree choice tend to fall into two categories. There’s the detached ‘let’s observe and analyse the habits of this strange sub-species’ type publications (which I always imagine being narrated by David Attenborough) and then there are the glorified blog post variety: ‘let’s bitch about how entitled parents act and how much better life is without kids.’ Now there’s a place for both those kinds of books (although both can get tiresome pretty quickly), but how refreshing to find that well-known childfree researcher and blogger, Laura Carroll (of La Vie Childfree) has attempted something a little different here. The Baby Matrix sets out to explore the roots of what Carroll calls “pronatalism”: the assumption that everyone is driven to reproduce and that this is the only path to a satisfying life. Examining history and anthropology as well as political and religious doctrine Carroll argues that the ‘biological clock’ is socially constructed and sets out to demonstrate how society (not to mention the environment) would be improved if humanity could now dispense with this outdated myth.

Carroll phrases this book as a call to arms, riffing on the idea in The Matrix of taking the red pill and seeing the lies you had previously believed to be truths. But despite this dramatic framing, it’s really quite a balanced book. She isn’t down on parents (except really bad parents, which is fair enough isn’t it?) and she doesn’t say that people shouldn’t have children, just that they should recognise doing so is a choice and privilege not a given right. Carroll’s writing style is fairly brisk and businesslike but this is an interesting little book and I found myself nodding along to so many of her proposals, even – dare I say it – the more radical ones. In fact, at times I found myself asking “I’m sorry isn’t that obvious?” But then I guess Carroll is probably preaching to the converted in my case. But I  think a lot of parents should read this too and just learn to make little changes, like saying to their own kids “if you have children when you grow up” rather than “when.” That would be a very quiet revolution, but it would be a step in the right direction.

This entry was posted in Book reviews and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to The Baby Matrix by Laura Carroll

  1. calrose42 says:

    I was going to read and review this book, but you have taken the work out of that for me. How kind of you. This review gives me great insight and only makes me want to go read the book, unlike some who may give away all the juicy details. Have you read any other child free books that you might wish to tell me are good reads?

    • roxploration says:

      Thanks so much for taking the time to comment. I’ve read a few other childfree books but they’ve tended to fall into the two camps I mention in this post, either very academic or really just a bitch-fest (which isn’t to say they’re not worth reading). Two that spring to mind are:

      “Two is Enough: A Couple’s Guide to Living Childless by Choice” by Laura S. Scott is quite academic but does contain a selection of interviews with childfree couples from an array of social and racial backgrounds. Some of their stories are very moving, some funny but they all feel very honest.

      Then there’s “Childfree and Loving it” by Nicki DeFago which is a fun, feisty read. It does ask a lot of important questions but feels more like pro-childfree propaganda than a balanced exploration. But then there are so many pro-parenting myths out there I think a bit of balance redress is no bad thing.

      Have you got any childfree titles you’d recommend to me or any other readers here?

      • calrose42 says:

        I haven’t started on my childfree book reviews. It is supposedly a new year’s revolution of mine which I plan to conquer and at least read one book.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s