White Ghost Girls by Alice Greenway

White Ghost Girls

Published: 2006 by Atlantic Books
My copy: borrowed from the Library where I work

Memorable quote: “And now I want to kill my father because he surrounds himself with so many people and adventures and stories that I will never reach him, never be able to tell him what happened to Frankie and me.”

Plenty gets written about the relationship between stage and screen: “the film based on the book, the book of the film” and so on. As far as I know White Ghost Girls does not have a film adaptation but this slim novel feels like a cinematic experience in its own right. Greenway’s short – sometimes fragmented – sentences erupt with colour and detail: “Red banners. Red flags. Little Red books of Mao Zedong’s edicts wave in the air.” Our narrator is Kate, a young American girl growing up in Hong Kong during the time of the Vietnam war. While her older sister Frankie rebels, revelling in curiosity, risk and her burgeoning sexuality, Kate remains quiet and watchful and, through the eyes of such an observant narrator, the readers become watchers too. This is both the great strength of White Ghost Girls and its weakness. When I finished this book it was wasn’t really Greenway’s plot or her characters that stayed with me, just a montage of some of her tremendously vivid imagery: intricate but static scenes rather like leafing through an old photograph album. This reaction may indicate that the novel’s plot is rather thin, which is certainly true, but more than that it emphasises the strikingly visual way in which Greenway writes.

The words “Vietnam” or “Chairman Mao” can unleash a flurry of moral and political debate, but while these sorts of questions do bubble away under the surface with gathering potency, what I enjoyed here was the different perspective on offer. Daily life continues even as epochs are made and unmade. Hong Kong’s privileged English speaking community cannot be unaffected by the violence and political unrest, but they strive to maintain an illusion of safety, detachment and above all, normality. The main consequence of war for Kate and Frankie is a desperate longing for their father, a war photographer who spends long periods away from home recording the conflict.  While the danger of his job adds another level of anxiety, the girls’ clingy attempts to stave off their increasing sense of alienation from him are something that anyone growing up with busy or partially absent parents can relate to.  Yet Kate’s elegiac story shows the damaging consequences of her parents’ well meaning attempts to shield her from the violence simmering around them. Unable to discuss or fully interpret the unsettling things she has seen, she retreats into herself, fear becoming another strand in the complex tangle of emotions and hormones in this haunting coming of age story.

White Ghost Girls is colourful novel of cultural clash: East and West, rich and poor, the violent and the mundane. Indeed through the unquestioning eyes of its juvenile narrator so quietly and fully are these different factors blended that story’s climax feels nowhere near as shocking as perhaps it should have done: sensitivity and numbness is another contrast to add to Greenway’s potent mix. More like a slide show than a novel, this fragmentary narrative will nonetheless immerse you in the fascinating, complex and troubling world of 1960s Hong Kong, a world of colour and conflict: temples, street markets, fishermen, swimming pool parties and revolutionaries. It’s a trip well worth taking.

This entry was posted in Book reviews and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to White Ghost Girls by Alice Greenway

  1. I’m intrigued – added this to my to-read list!

  2. roxploration says:

    Thanks, and nice to hear from you. This is just one I randomly plucked off the shelf at work – intrigued by the title more than anything, but it is very immersive and cinematic.

  3. what caught my eye is the title, I used to call that way myself but my husband said it’s not really how they use it in HK – when they reffer to ghost girl they mean white foreigner, don’t need to add ‘white’, they only add ‘black’ if necessary 🙂 but I will have to read that book

    • roxploration says:

      Hi! Thanks for checking out my blog and taking the time to comment. It’s particularly interesting to hear from someone with firsthand experience of the location. Greenway lived in Hong Kong as a child so I think the story is partly drawn from memoir but I’d be fascinated to hear your take on it.

  4. Carole says:

    Hi there, just letting you know that you are in my Featured Book Blog sidebar for October on Carole’s Chatter. Have a great week. Cheers

    • roxploration says:

      Ooh that’s great, thanks so much for your support, I really appreciate it. Sorry I didn’t have anything to add to your last collection, I guess my tastes don;t run particularly humorous. Will definitely contribute next time though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s